New York - Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center
HOURS
Monday
11AM - 7PM
Tuesday
11AM - 7PM
Wednesday
11AM - 7PM
Thursday
11AM - 7PM
Friday
11AM - 7PM
Saturday
11AM - 7PM
Sunday
11AM - 7PM
It's 3:26PM in New York right now
Show Off Your Haul
Been here? Share your best finds and haul photos!
About This Store
Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center in New York is one of the go-to New York thrift stores for anyone serious about thrift shopping. As part of the Goodwill chain, it’s known for supporting community programs through its sales, which makes shopping here feel good on more levels than one. The store is consistently stocked with a diverse mix of used clothing, from everyday basics to vintage pieces that catch the eye.
This location is more than just clothes. Shoppers can expect to find furniture, housewares, books, and sometimes unusual collectibles—all priced to encourage digging through racks and shelves. The furniture selection in particular can be a nice surprise, offering sturdy pieces that can be given a little TLC or left as is. It’s a place where every visit could bring a different mix of items, depending on recent donations.
New York thrift store finds at Goodwill NYNJ
Exploring this New York thrift store means encountering that familiar thrill of spotting something both affordable and unique. The vintage section is worth a look, with various eras represented depending on the day. The store’s organization makes it easy to browse by category, which is great when you want to focus on specific thrift shopping goals like refreshing your wardrobe or sprucing up your living space with secondhand décor.
Overall, Goodwill NYNJ blends the community-driven mission Goodwill is famous for with a solid selection of everyday and vintage goods. It’s a reliable spot if you want to combine sustainable shopping habits with the hunt for quality secondhand clothing or home items in New York.
Looking for more options? Explore other thrift stores in New York or visit the Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center website for details.
Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.
Location
Thrift Hauls
Google Reviews
2 months ago
Superb!! You must know your way around Goodwill and have the time and patience to score. I see some people give it 1star; but, I don't think they [are Goodwill savi]know how to shop.
a year ago
All goodwills are getting expensive but you can still find affordable gems. Very kind staff.
4 years ago
This used to be a good Goodwill store but now its like...meh... The workers have no pride in their store, its was dirty and unkempt. The donations where piled into a heap right in the front of the store. They had shirts for $15.99. Come on now, these are items that are donated or thrown away! The security is ridiculous, the last time I was here I saw a lady shoplifting! I don't think I will be returning any time soon. Goodwill is located on 1114 1st Ave. New York City. Opens at 10am
a month ago
Avoid this place! I bought a coat here after the salesman assured me it was a men’s jacket, only to find out it’s actually a women’s coat. When I came back, the manager was incredibly disrespectful and refused to listen. She even threatened to call the police if I didn't leave within 5 seconds—all because I asked for what I deserved after being scammed. Worst customer service ever.
8 months ago
Original Review: 6/6/2025 I purchased a suit from this location today and when I got home and went to hang it up, a dead bedbug dropped out of it. 6/7/2025 Edit: When I went back, I spoke with the manager, he didn’t seem to care this happened. He didn’t indicate anything would be done to rectify it both in the immediate term and in the longer term. I’m extremely disappointed that Goodwill explicitly is prioritizing their intake metrics over safety. 6/30/2025 Edit: While it would be unethical for me to say that Goodwill gave me bedbugs, I can say with certainty that after purchasing the suit, I started getting bed bug bites within days and am now being treated for a very new bed bug issue at my apartment. It could be just a coincidence to have things line up…but it probably isn’t.
