New York - Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center
HOURS
Monday
11AM - 7PM
Tuesday
11AM - 7PM
Wednesday
11AM - 7PM
Thursday
11AM - 7PM
Friday
11AM - 7PM
Saturday
11AM - 7PM
Sunday
11AM - 7PM
It's 3:25PM in New York right now
Show Off Your Haul
Been here? Share your best finds and haul photos!
About This Store
Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center in New York is a solid spot for anyone serious about thrift shopping. This New York thrift store is part of the larger Goodwill chain, which is well-known for supporting local communities by turning donations into affordable goods. You’ll find a wide variety of used clothing here, from everyday casual wear to some unexpected vintage pieces for those who enjoy digging through racks. The selection constantly changes, reflecting the diverse donations from the city’s residents.
New York thrift store shopping at Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center
If you’re into secondhand furniture and housewares, this Goodwill location often stocks everything from sturdy chairs to kitchen gadgets and decorative items. It’s a great place to browse if you want to outfit your apartment without blowing your budget. Books and media also show up regularly, so keep an eye out for those if you enjoy flipping through used novels or hunting down classic vinyl. You never know what will be waiting on any given day.
The Goodwill brand is known for its role in creating jobs and training programs funded by store profits, which makes shopping here feel a bit more rewarding. While the store is definitely geared towards practical finds, those patient enough to sift through their racks can uncover some very cool vintage clothing or accessories. Overall, Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center is a reliable go-to for anyone who appreciates the mix of thrifting and supporting community causes in New York.
Looking for more options? Explore other thrift stores in New York or visit the Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center website for details.
Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.
Location
Thrift Hauls
Google Reviews
a year ago
One of my favorite shops in NYC. Has hidden gems. Update* Still one of my favorite thrift shops in NYC but the prices have gotten out of control for some items. Like I don't care if it was a higher priced ticket item originally if it's obviously really worn out and has pills on the fabric. Even the shoes are over priced now. It's like they are trying to compete with the online resale market but don't actually monitor the going rates to be able to realize that they are over pricing items. There's still some gems but you have to work more to find them and then hope that it is actually in your size (they color coordinate everything but not by size) and hope it is reasonably priced.
2 years ago
Really like the way the goodwill is organized. There is a section for more expensive items for people who can afford thrift stores for fashion choices. While there is the general area where people who need the lower-priced items can afford them. The system here is a feasible solution we see where thrift stores that usually serve people in need of lower-priced items are no longer able to afford thrifting because the clothes are marked up due to the demand on thrifting and the rise in thrifting as a fashion choice. Good system!
a month ago
I came here to donate clothes that Buffalo Exchange wouldn’t buy from me. I honestly like the selection of clothes here at Goodwill than at the Buffalo Exchange. It seems like many people come here to donate after such rejection. I like that there’s a mix of good basics and fashionable pieces here, and not just trending/overwhelming nonsense. Despite most thrift prices going up in recent years, I would say this store prices most things fairly. I bought a vertical striped grey Calvin Klein button down in really good condition. It was a steal to me at $7.99, and it wasn’t even something I had to dig for. It was just sitting on the end of a rack (though I don’t mind the digging). I also like that clothes are sorted by type and color - I read a review that said they didn’t like that it wasn’t sorted by size. I discovered that there’s a kind of “rewards” program here, and discount on weekends if you’re a student. Like other Goodwills there’s also a specific color tag of the day, which probably indicates that these items are discounted. Overall 4 stars because I wish there were more accessories, household items, books, etc.
a month ago
Store selection is limited. For men if your looking for 38 and up in jeans it aint happening. they also organize their clothing by color not size so your forced to go through every single rack to find out they dont have your size very annoying. Also I get that its manhattan but trying to charge retail or close to retail for items is absolutely outrageous !!!
a month ago
Extremely Rude and the security Guard who mentioned below closes the store over 10 minute prior to closing and only lets specific people in when he wants to. Come in to make a complaint to manager said they close the store at 6.55pm when I come before that and didn't want to listen or resolve issues and the security guard come interjected in our conversation and stated harassing me I started recording as this was discraseful behavior and spoke to different Goodwill manager who gave me corporate information and told me they wrong cannot close their store early and should newer be acting this way. Both Manager and security guard should be let go for the distressful behavior and I will be sending video to corporate and they can check their store cameras as well.
