New York - Buffalo Exchange
HOURS
Monday
11AM - 8PM
Tuesday
11AM - 8PM
Wednesday
11AM - 8PM
Thursday
11AM - 8PM
Friday
11AM - 8PM
Saturday
11AM - 8PM
Sunday
11AM - 7PM
It's 9:02PM in New York right now
Show Off Your Haul
Been here? Share your best finds and haul photos!
About This Store
Buffalo Exchange in New York is a standout New York thrift store that’s part of a well-known chain celebrated for quality secondhand clothing and thoughtful curation. Unlike many thrift stores that feel overwhelming, Buffalo Exchange balances a cool, urban vibe with organized racks that make thrift shopping enjoyable and efficient. The store attracts a mix of fashion enthusiasts and casual shoppers, all digging through an ever-changing selection of used clothing and vintage pieces.
This New York thrift store specializes in wearable, stylish items that range from trendy streetwear to classic vintage finds. You’ll find everything from denim, jackets, and dresses to unique accessories that can easily refresh any wardrobe. While Buffalo Exchange mainly focuses on clothing and accessories, some locations also offer a small but interesting mix of shoes and bags. It’s not your place for furniture or housewares, but if clothes are your main interest, this spot is worth a visit.
New York thrift store for vintage and secondhand clothing
Buffalo Exchange is known for its buy-sell-trade model, which means the inventory is always rotating with new pieces brought in by customers. This creates a shopping experience full of surprises, where you might stumble on something vintage from decades past or a barely worn trendy jacket. The New York thrift store’s staff are usually knowledgeable and ready to help, which makes the whole vibe friendly and accessible, even if you’re new to thrift shopping. For anyone who enjoys mixing vintage with modern or is looking for high-quality used clothing in New York, Buffalo Exchange delivers without the clutter and chaos typical of larger thrift stores. It’s a place where secondhand shopping feels curated but still full of variety.
Looking for more options? Explore other thrift stores in New York or visit the Buffalo Exchange website for details.
Hip chain that buys, sells, trades trendy vintage & used clothing plus accessories for men & women.
Location
Thrift Hauls
Google Reviews
8 months ago
Update - very packed and a lot of low quality items in the mix. By far one of my favorite thrift store. They buy your clothes very fairly and let you know why they are selecting your items. They go through your stuff right in front of you which is great so there is no confusion later on what was taken or left behind and they price it in front of you so if you change your mind you can always just take an item back if you do not like the pricing. The staff are amazing and work together as a team to run the store efficiently.
a year ago
Most people are going to review this place based on if they found something that they liked, which is a little unfair, LOL. I'll agree with other reviewers that it's pretty easy to navigate, they have lots of choices, and it's not crazily priced. I found two things that I liked a whole lot and we'll go back next time I'm in New York...
a year ago
a decent spot for secondhand clothing, but it has its ups and downs. The store offers a variety of styles, from vintage to modern pieces, and the layout is easy to navigate. However, the pricing can be inconsistent—some items feel overpriced for secondhand goods, while others are more reasonable. The selection depends heavily on timing. On some visits, I’ve found great pieces, but on others, the inventory felt picked over or lacking in variety. The staff are generally polite but can sometimes come across as rushed, especially during busy hours. If you’re patient and don’t mind sifting through racks, you can find quality items here. It’s worth stopping by if you’re in the area, but it might not always deliver the thrift shopping excitement you’re hoping for. Finally, it is kinda small for a Buffalo Exchange
a week ago
used to be my favorite thrift shop in the entirety of manhattan but not anymore :( i don’t know if i missed a rebrand or what - this location used to be overflowing with vintage gems and now it is strictly shein and zara. every hanger was either objectively ugly or brand-new ultra fast fashion. they also don’t have the wall telling you what they’re looking for at that location anymore: it just says “spring!” … staff was nice/chill but the stock was the worst i’ve ever seen across boroughs. genuinely so devastated
3 weeks ago
Horrible place. when you first walk in, the store had a smell of dirty old clothes. ( that should've been the first sign to leave!) Then as I was looking through the rack, there was a white male worker following me as thought I was there to steal (there was the second sign!) I felt really uncomfortable because I wasn't there to steal, I was there to shop! Nonetheless, I continued to browse around only to be disappointed in their selection of used clothing. I would never go back there to this particular one. (There are others) Not a good selection of clothes there and, I thought racism and racial profiling was over (well partially!) Totally disappointed 😞
