Chicago - Buffalo Exchange
HOURS
Monday
11AM - 8PM
Tuesday
11AM - 8PM
Wednesday
11AM - 8PM
Thursday
11AM - 8PM
Friday
11AM - 8PM
Saturday
11AM - 8PM
Sunday
11AM - 8PM
It's 10:26AM in Chicago right now
Show Off Your Haul
Been here? Share your best finds and haul photos!
About This Store
Shopping at Chicago Buffalo Exchange
If you’re into thrift shopping in Chicago, Buffalo Exchange is a spot you’ll want to check out. This Chicago Buffalo Exchange location is part of a well-known chain that’s been around for decades, recognized for its carefully selected used clothing and vintage pieces that appeal to a range of style tastes. Unlike many thrift stores where you might have to dig through piles to find something good, Buffalo Exchange tends to keep the racks organized and trendy, making the experience more approachable for shoppers who appreciate both thrift and style.
Buffalo Exchange in Chicago specializes in clothing, but you’ll also find accessories and some unique fashion-forward items that lean vintage or gently used. The store’s inventory often includes everything from classic denim jackets and band tees to quirky dresses and statement shoes. While it’s mostly focused on apparel, occasionally you might spot some secondhand bags or jewelry that complement the clothing lineup. It’s not a place where you’ll find bulky furniture or housewares, but if your goal is to refresh your wardrobe with quality secondhand items, this is definitely a store worth spending time at.
The vibe at this Chicago Buffalo Exchange is casual and welcoming, and the staff usually know their stock well, which is great if you want some quick tips or suggestions. The store buys and trades clothing too, which means you can bring in your own used items and get credit or cash toward new finds. That’s a neat way to keep your closet rotating without contributing to waste. For anyone serious about Chicago thrift, Buffalo Exchange offers a reliable, well-curated experience that balances the thrill of thrifting with a bit more polish and style.
Looking for more options? Explore other thrift stores in Chicago or visit the Buffalo Exchange website for details.
Hip chain that buys, sells, trades trendy vintage & used clothing plus accessories for men & women.
Location
Thrift Hauls
Google Reviews
3 years ago
They had lots of cool clothes and accessories including seasonal Halloween costumes. Someone had a basket of clothes to sell and their wait was 10-15 minutes to process it, no one ahead of them. This was on a Saturday afternoon. The clothes racks are tightly packed together and you have to shimmy past people so I don't think it would be very accessible for a wheelchair.
a month ago
I went here to sell and had a good experience. The employee who helped me was friendly and transparent about the process. That said, I've been in here a few times as a customer and rarely find things I like. This was highlighted today when my favorite clothes I brought in were rejected and my least favorite were bought, lol. I guess I'm just super out of sync with the current styles! If you are into things like graphic tees, tank tops, etc then you will have better luck here. I'm more of an oxford button down and jeans person and they don't really cater to that style.
4 months ago
The store is always well organized, with racks full of trendy, vintage, and unique pieces that cater to every style and budget. The quality of the clothing and accessories is impressive — everything feels carefully selected and in great condition. Whether you’re looking for something bold and expressive or just want to refresh your wardrobe sustainably, you’re almost guaranteed to find a hidden gem here. The atmosphere is upbeat and creative, making every visit feel like a mini fashion treasure hunt.
8 months ago
The store is in the hot of Andersonville and the staff are friendly and fun to talk with. Depending on the fashion of today, they will give you either money for your clothes in cash or store credit which will be a lot more. So bring your stuff in good and washed condition because that will help your situation And see what you can get for the things that you don’t want anymore.
6 months ago
I live in the neighborhood and always love seeing what’s new in store! Over my past recent visits there has been a decrease in the XL and above sizes. I brought Clothes in to sell and unfortunately I overheard an employees comment about one of my items that maybe a coincidence or a potential reason for the decrease in these sizes. Two employees were talking about how cute one of my items was until one of them looked at the size ( it’s was a size XL) and one employee said to the other one “if it wasn’t a big persons size”. The employee did not know I heard the comment but definitely hope for better experiences especially in a neighborhood as diverse and inclusive as Andersonville claims to be.
