Been here? Share your best finds and haul photos!
Horizon Goodwill Retail Store in Greencastle is one of those dependable spots that anyone who enjoys thrift shopping should know about. As part of the Goodwill chain, it carries the reputation for a steady flow of donated goods that range from everyday basics to interesting vintage pieces. Goodwill stores like this one are known for supporting community programs, so shopping here feels like a little win beyond just scoring some secondhand finds.
Walking into the Greencastle thrift store, you’ll find a mix of things organized well enough to make browsing pleasant rather than overwhelming. The clothing section has a solid selection of used clothing, from casual wear to occasional vintage gems. It’s the kind of place where you can take your time flipping through racks without rushing. Beyond apparel, Horizon’s shelves and aisles hold housewares, books, and sometimes furniture. The furniture tends to lean toward practical pieces — think small tables, chairs, and shelves that can fit nicely into an apartment or starter home.
If you’re into vintage items, it pays to check in regularly. The stock changes constantly, and sometimes you’ll stumble on retro décor or collectible books. Horizon Goodwill in Greencastle is the kind of thrift store where patience pays off. You won’t find a curated boutique, but the range and volume of secondhand goods give you ample opportunity to find something that fits your style and budget. For anyone who loves the thrill of thrift shopping in Greencastle, this store is a solid stop to keep on your list.
Looking for more options? Explore other thrift stores in Greencastle or visit the Horizon Goodwill Retail Store website for details.
Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.
I loved this store. The employees are happy and willing to help you with whatever you need. I found the prices very reasonable and the cleanliness of the store was also great. Organization of products is right on. The only thing I didn't like was the price of the books. Number 1 resale item for resellers. Can't pay $2.00. too much, sorry guys that's my opinion.
First time here at this Goodwill store. I enjoyed the variety of items but thought that some of items were priced high. The book section was much higher than most other thrift store.
Lots of items, pretty well organized. Housewares are pricey
Line of customers and the cashier took 5 minutes to line up hangers. 8 people waiting to checkout. Poor customer service.
I want to love this store because the people our super nice but it's small and it doesn't have much to offer